- 2018
- Woman of the Year: Chelsee Wilson, Concordia Chicago
- Man of the Year: Kevin Coppin, Concordia Chicago
- 2017
- Woman of the Year: Holly Haberkorn, Benedictine
- Man of the Year: Eric Kittel, Concordia Wisconsin
- 2016
- Woman of the Year: Nicci Bermudes, Aurora
- Man of the Year: Logan Andryk, MSOE
- 2015
- Woman of the Year: Loretta Johnson, Aurora
- Co-Men of the Year: Logan Marvin, Dominican & Aaron Roeseler, Wisconsin Lutheran
- 2014
- Woman of the Year: Jenee Lange, Aurora
- Man of the Year: Eric Zeitler, Wisconsin Lutheran
- 2013
- Woman of the Year: Torey DeLozier, Maranatha
- Man of the Year: Doug Ingold, Aurora
- 2012
- Woman of the Year: Carol Cayo, MSOE
- Man of the Year: Tim Mackey, Aurora
- 2011
- Woman of the Year: Cait Hartman, Aurora
- Man of the Year: Austin Meier, MSOE
- 2010
- Woman of the Year: KC Blahnik, Lakeland
- Co-Men of the Year: Steve Salazar, Aurora & Brock Solveson, Concordia Wisconsin
- 2009
- Woman of the Year: Megan Scheele, Edgewood
- Man of the Year: Zach Bickel, Concordia Chicago
- 2008
- Woman of the Year: Catherine Chappell, MSOE
- Man of the Year: Jordan Van Ess, Marian
- 2007
- Woman of the Year: Emily Henrich, Wisconsin Lutheran